Back to Blog
Insurance Guide
January 5, 2025
6 min read

Device Insurance vs Manufacturer Warranty: Which Should You Choose?

Understanding the key differences between device insurance and manufacturer warranties. Make an informed decision about protecting your tech investments.

Device Insurance vs Manufacturer Warranty: Which Should You Choose?

When buying a new device, you're often presented with two protection options: manufacturer warranty and device insurance. Understanding the differences is crucial for making the right choice. This guide breaks down both options to help you decide.


Manufacturer Warranty: The Basics


What It Covers

Manufacturer warranties typically cover:

  • Defects in Materials or Workmanship: Manufacturing flaws
  • Hardware Failures: Component malfunctions under normal use
  • First Year Protection: Usually 1 year from purchase date
  • Limited Coverage: Only covers what the manufacturer deems defective

What It DOESN'T Cover

Manufacturer warranties exclude:

  • Accidental damage (drops, spills)
  • Theft or loss
  • Water damage
  • Cosmetic damage
  • Normal wear and tear
  • User error

Cost

  • Included with Purchase: Free with your device
  • Extended Warranties: $100-$300 for additional years

Limitations

  • Must prove manufacturing defect
  • Often requires shipping device to manufacturer
  • Repair or replacement at manufacturer's discretion
  • Usually limited to original owner

Device Insurance: Comprehensive Protection


What It Covers

Device insurance provides broader coverage:

  • Accidental Damage: Drops, spills, cracks
  • Theft and Loss: Full replacement
  • Water Damage: Protection against liquid spills
  • Malfunctions: Beyond manufacturer warranty period
  • Multiple Devices: Some plans cover multiple items

What It DOESN'T Cover

Device insurance typically excludes:

  • Intentional damage
  • Pre-existing conditions
  • Unauthorized repairs
  • Software issues

Cost

  • Monthly Premium: $29.99-$39.99/month
  • Deductibles: $0-$100 per claim (depending on plan)
  • Cancel Anytime: More flexibility than warranties

Benefits

  • Faster claims processing
  • Local repair options
  • Covers user-caused damage
  • Theft and loss protection
  • Extended coverage beyond warranty period

Key Differences at a Glance



Real-World Scenarios


Scenario 1: Screen Crack After Drop

  • Warranty: ❌ Not covered (accidental damage)
  • Insurance: ✅ Covered (accidental damage)
  • Your Cost: $0 (insurance) vs $200-$600 (out-of-pocket)

Scenario 2: Battery Degradation After 2 Years

  • Warranty: ❌ Expired (1-year coverage)
  • Insurance: ✅ Covered (ongoing protection)
  • Your Cost: $0-$50 (deductible) vs $100-$300 (replacement)

Scenario 3: Phone Stolen

  • Warranty: ❌ Not covered (theft excluded)
  • Insurance: ✅ Covered (theft protection in Elite/Ultimate)
  • Your Cost: Replacement device vs $800-$1500+ (new phone)

Scenario 4: Hardware Failure (Year 1)

  • Warranty: ✅ Covered (manufacturing defect)
  • Insurance: ✅ Also covered (backup protection)
  • Your Cost: $0 (use warranty first)

Which Should You Choose?


Manufacturer Warranty is Enough If:

  • You're very careful with devices
  • You only want free basic protection
  • You accept risk of accidental damage
  • Budget is extremely tight

Device Insurance is Better If:

  • You want comprehensive protection
  • You're accident-prone
  • Your device is expensive
  • You travel frequently
  • You want theft protection
  • You value peace of mind

Best Approach: Use Both!


The Smart Strategy:

1. Year 1: Rely on manufacturer warranty for defects

2. Year 1+: Device insurance for accidents and extended coverage

3. Ongoing: Insurance for theft, loss, and long-term protection


This gives you:

  • Year 1: Double protection (warranty + insurance)
  • Year 2+: Continued insurance protection
  • Best Value: Coverage when warranty expires

Honar Insurance Plans


We offer flexible plans that complement manufacturer warranties:


Premium Protect ($29.99/month)

  • Accidental damage
  • Water damage
  • Hardware failures
  • Screen repairs

Elite Shield ($34.99/month)

  • Everything in Premium
  • Theft & Loss Coverage (key differentiator from warranty)
  • Priority repairs

Ultimate Business ($39.99/month)

  • Everything in Elite
  • Multiple devices
  • International coverage

Conclusion


Manufacturer warranties provide basic free protection, but they have significant limitations. Device insurance offers comprehensive coverage for accidents, theft, and long-term protection.


The Bottom Line: For expensive devices or peace of mind, device insurance is worth the investment. For maximum protection, use both warranty (first year) and insurance (ongoing).


Ready to protect your device? Get insurance with Honar and enjoy comprehensive protection beyond your warranty.


Ready to Protect Your Devices?

Get comprehensive device insurance starting at $29.99/month

Get a Quote Now
Device Insurance vs Manufacturer Warranty: Which Should You Choose? | Honar Insurance Blog | Honar Insurance